The Tearsmith (Fabbricante di Lacrime), an Italian Netflix film based on Erin Doom’s novel, has been making waves in the YA romance genre. However, before you settle in for a movie night with your teen, it’s crucial to consider whether this film is actually appropriate for younger audiences. This review dives into why The Tearsmith might not be the teen-friendly romance you expect, acting as your parents guide to the film’s content and suitability.
While the young actors Caterina Ferioli and Simone Baldasseroni give commendable performances as Nica and Rigel, the movie itself struggles to deliver a compelling story. Set in an orphanage with a cruel mistress, the plot quickly becomes convoluted and difficult to follow. The narrative jumps erratically, and constant, distracting narration makes it challenging to grasp the relationships and motivations of the characters. Parents should be aware that the film’s murky and fast-paced plot might be frustrating for younger viewers seeking a straightforward romance.
The Tearsmith
One of the main concerns for parents will be the film’s TV-MA rating. This mature rating is primarily due to language and intimacy scenes. Although the review thankfully notes the film avoids explicit nudity, it does feature “one and a half mediocre intimacy scenes” which contribute to the mature rating. Parents should consider if they are comfortable with their teenagers viewing these types of scenes, even if they are described as “mediocre.”
Beyond the rating, The Tearsmith attempts to create a dark and melodramatic atmosphere, but falls short. The constant use of overly dramatic music and dimly lit scenes contributes to a heavy tone that may not resonate with all viewers. The film also borrows heavily from familiar YA tropes, seemingly aiming for a Twilight-esque vibe, complete with angsty teenagers and pop songs by artists like Olivia Rodrigo and Billie Eilish. However, it lacks the engaging plot and relatable characters that made Twilight popular.
Furthermore, the central relationship between Nica and Rigel is underdeveloped and unconvincing. The review highlights the lack of chemistry and unclear reasons for their attraction. This central romance, which should be the heart of the film, feels hollow, making it difficult for viewers to connect with the characters or their supposed love story. For parents seeking films with positive relationship models, The Tearsmith may disappoint.
In conclusion, The Tearsmith is described as “an utterly confusing, absolutely uninteresting mess of a movie” with “no redeeming qualities.” While your teen might be drawn to the film’s genre and Netflix prominence, this parents guide suggests caution. The TV-MA rating, confusing plot, and lack of engaging content make The Tearsmith a questionable choice for family viewing or for younger teenagers seeking a wholesome romance. It might be best to steer your teens towards more thoughtfully crafted and age-appropriate options.
