A Break With Charity Study Guide, crucial for understanding Ann Rinaldi’s historical novel, offers a comprehensive analysis of the Salem Witch Trials through the eyes of Susanna English. At CONDUCT.EDU.VN, we provide educational resources, including this study guide, to navigate the complexities of morality, mass hysteria, and historical context. Discover ethical guidelines and responsible behavior as you explore the themes of guilt, forgiveness, and social responsibility.
1. Understanding the Historical Context of the Salem Witch Trials
The Salem Witch Trials, a dark chapter in American history, took place in 1692 in Salem Village, Massachusetts. Understanding the historical context is crucial for grasping the events in A Break with Charity.
1.1 The Social and Religious Climate
Puritan society in 17th-century New England was deeply religious, with a strict moral code and a belief in the supernatural. According to the Massachusetts Historical Society, “The Puritans believed that the Devil was active in the world and could empower individuals, known as witches, to harm others.” This fear of the Devil and witchcraft was pervasive, leading to an environment ripe for hysteria.
1.2 Political Instability
The Massachusetts Bay Colony was undergoing political instability, with a new charter from England and conflicts with Native Americans. This instability created anxiety and uncertainty, which contributed to the witch hunt. As historian Frances Hill notes in A Delusion of Satan, “The political and social tensions in Salem Village exacerbated the fear of witchcraft.”
1.3 Key Figures
Several key figures played significant roles in the Salem Witch Trials:
- Reverend Samuel Parris: The minister of Salem Village whose daughter and niece were among the first accusers.
- Tituba: The Parris family’s slave, who was among the first to be accused of witchcraft.
- Ann Putnam Jr.: One of the primary accusers, whose accusations led to the arrest and execution of many innocent people.
- Judge Samuel Sewall: A judge who presided over the trials and later publicly apologized for his role in the injustice.
2. Key Characters in A Break with Charity
Understanding the main characters is essential for analyzing the plot and themes of A Break with Charity.
2.1 Susanna English
Susanna English is the protagonist of the novel. She is a young girl caught in the midst of the witch hysteria. Initially, Susanna is naive and longs to be accepted by the popular group of girls. However, as the trials progress, she becomes more aware of the injustice and takes a stand against the accusations. Susanna’s journey reflects the moral awakening of an individual in the face of societal pressure.
2.2 Ann Putnam Jr.
Ann Putnam Jr. is a central figure in the witch accusations. She is portrayed as manipulative and power-hungry, using the accusations to gain attention and avoid chores. Ann’s actions drive much of the conflict in the novel. Her public apology at the end of the story provides a sense of closure, but also raises questions about the nature of forgiveness and accountability.
2.3 Tituba
Tituba, the Parris family’s slave, is a complex character. She is initially presented as a mysterious figure who dabbles in folk magic. However, as the hysteria intensifies, she becomes a scapegoat for the villagers’ fears. Tituba’s character highlights the vulnerability of marginalized individuals in times of social upheaval.
2.4 Other Important Characters
- William English: Susanna’s brother, a sailor whose fate becomes intertwined with the witch accusations.
- Mr. and Mrs. English: Susanna’s parents, who are arrested and imprisoned due to the accusations.
- Johnathan: Susanna’s crush, who initially believes in the witch accusations but eventually comes to see the truth.
3. Plot Summary: Unfolding the Drama
The plot of A Break with Charity follows Susanna English as she navigates the events of the Salem Witch Trials.
3.1 Introduction to Salem Village (1691)
The novel opens in 1706, with Susanna reflecting on the events of the past. The story then flashes back to 1691, introducing the reader to Salem Village and the social dynamics of the community. Susanna longs to be accepted by the group of girls who gather at Reverend Parris’s house.
3.2 The Girls’ Witchcraft Dabbling
Behind closed doors, the girls dabble in witchery and spell-conjuring with the help of Tituba. Susanna learns about their activities and realizes that some of them are pretending to be possessed. This act quickly gains attention, leading to widespread panic among the villagers.
3.3 Accusations and Hysteria
The girls’ odd behavior is quickly noticed, and the villagers’ fears of witchery envelop Salem in widespread panic. Accusations begin to fly, and innocent people are arrested and imprisoned. The hysteria intensifies as more and more people are accused of witchcraft.
3.4 Susanna’s Dilemma
Susanna is convinced that the girls are faking, but she is threatened by Ann Putnam Jr. Ann warns Susanna that if she reveals the truth, Ann will accuse the English family of witchcraft. Susanna must decide whether to stay silent to protect her family or speak out against the injustice.
3.5 Arrest and Imprisonment of the English Family
One day, Susanna’s mother defends the sister of an accused witch, leading to her arrest. Soon after, Mr. English is also arrested. Susanna and her sister, Mary, go to stay with family friends. Mr. and Mrs. English are eventually released from jail and flee to Boston with Mary, but Susanna remains in Salem.
3.6 The Trials and Hangings
A new governor is installed in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and he is a firm believer in witchcraft. Courts begin hearing cases of accused witches, and many are hanged for their alleged crimes. The trials and hangings create a climate of fear and desperation in Salem.
3.7 Susanna’s Courageous Stand
Susanna finally decides to take a stand against the injustice. She tells Joseph, a friend with connections to powerful judges, the truth about the girls’ behavior. She also meets with Mary Bradbury, an accused witch, and realizes that the rumors about her are false.
3.8 The End of the Hysteria
Susanna goes to Reverend Pike and an influential merchant named Thomas Brattle, telling them the truth about the supposed witches in Salem. They use their power in the community to speak out against the injustices, inspiring others to do the same. The trials and killings come to an end.
3.9 Resolution (1706)
Back in 1706, Susanna witnesses Ann Putnam Jr.’s public apology. She decides to forgive Ann and move forward with her life, marrying Johnathan and finding happiness. The novel concludes with a reflection on the lasting impact of the Salem Witch Trials on the community and the nation.
4. Themes Explored in A Break with Charity
A Break with Charity explores several important themes that are relevant to contemporary society.
4.1 Mass Hysteria
Mass hysteria is a central theme in the novel. The events in Salem demonstrate how fear and paranoia can spread rapidly through a community, leading to irrational behavior and injustice. The novel highlights the dangers of allowing emotions to override reason.
4.2 Guilt and Forgiveness
The characters in A Break with Charity grapple with feelings of guilt and the possibility of forgiveness. Ann Putnam Jr. must confront her role in the witch trials and seek redemption. Susanna must decide whether to forgive Ann and move forward with her life. The novel explores the complexities of these emotions and the challenges of reconciliation.
4.3 Social Responsibility
The novel emphasizes the importance of social responsibility. Susanna’s decision to speak out against the injustice demonstrates the power of individual action in the face of societal pressure. The novel encourages readers to consider their own responsibility to stand up for what is right, even when it is difficult.
4.4 The Power of Truth
The power of truth is another significant theme. Susanna’s courageous act of revealing the truth about the girls’ behavior ultimately brings an end to the witch trials. The novel underscores the importance of seeking truth and speaking out against deception.
4.5 Justice and Injustice
The events in Salem highlight the fragility of justice and the potential for injustice. The novel raises questions about the fairness of the legal system and the importance of protecting the rights of the accused. It serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of allowing fear and prejudice to influence legal proceedings.
5. Literary Devices Used by Ann Rinaldi
Ann Rinaldi employs several literary devices to enhance the storytelling in A Break with Charity.
5.1 Point of View
The novel is told from Susanna English’s first-person point of view. This allows the reader to experience the events through Susanna’s eyes and gain insight into her thoughts and feelings. The first-person perspective creates a sense of intimacy and immediacy, drawing the reader into the story.
5.2 Historical Accuracy
Rinaldi incorporates historical details and events into the novel to create a sense of authenticity. She draws on primary and secondary sources to accurately depict the social, religious, and political climate of Salem in 1692. This historical accuracy enhances the reader’s understanding of the events and their significance.
5.3 Symbolism
Symbolism is used throughout the novel to convey deeper meanings. For example, the witch trials themselves can be seen as a symbol of the dangers of mass hysteria and the abuse of power. The characters and events in the story often represent broader themes and ideas.
5.4 Irony
Irony is used to highlight the contradictions and absurdities of the situation in Salem. For example, the girls who are accusing others of witchcraft are themselves engaged in deceptive behavior. This irony underscores the moral complexities of the story.
5.5 Foreshadowing
Foreshadowing is used to create suspense and hint at future events. For example, early in the novel, there are subtle clues that suggest the English family will become targets of the accusations. This foreshadowing adds depth and complexity to the narrative.
6. Analyzing Key Quotes from the Novel
Analyzing key quotes can provide deeper insights into the themes and characters of A Break with Charity.
6.1 “I knew that holding onto the pain of the past wouldn’t serve anyone.”
This quote, spoken by Susanna at the end of the novel, reflects her decision to forgive Ann Putnam Jr. and move forward with her life. It highlights the theme of forgiveness and the importance of letting go of past grievances.
6.2 “It was a very dangerous game Ann and the other girls were playing.”
This quote, spoken by Susanna early in the novel, foreshadows the tragic consequences of the girls’ deceptive behavior. It underscores the theme of social responsibility and the dangers of playing with power.
6.3 “Nineteen innocent people died because they refused to confess to something of which they were not guilty.”
This quote reflects on the tragic outcome of the Salem Witch Trials and the injustice suffered by the accused. It highlights the themes of justice and injustice, and the importance of standing up for one’s beliefs.
6.4 “The village of Salem is forever changed.”
This quote acknowledges the lasting impact of the witch trials on the community and the nation. It serves as a reminder of the dangers of mass hysteria and the importance of learning from the mistakes of the past.
6.5 “I seemed to be starting to believe in witches myself…”
This quote illustrates Susanna’s internal conflict and the pervasive influence of fear and paranoia during the witch trials. It highlights the theme of mass hysteria and the challenges of maintaining reason in the face of societal pressure.
7. Ethical Considerations in A Break with Charity
A Break with Charity raises several ethical considerations that are relevant to contemporary discussions about morality and social responsibility.
7.1 The Ethics of Accusation
The novel explores the ethics of accusation and the potential for false accusations to ruin lives. The girls’ accusations are motivated by self-interest and a desire for attention, leading to the unjust persecution of innocent people. The novel raises questions about the responsibility of individuals to ensure the accuracy of their accusations and the potential consequences of making false claims.
7.2 The Ethics of Silence
The novel also examines the ethics of silence and the moral implications of remaining silent in the face of injustice. Susanna initially chooses to remain silent to protect her family, but she eventually realizes that her silence contributes to the harm being done. The novel raises questions about the responsibility of individuals to speak out against wrongdoing, even when it is difficult or dangerous.
7.3 The Ethics of Forgiveness
The novel explores the ethics of forgiveness and the challenges of reconciling with those who have caused harm. Susanna’s decision to forgive Ann Putnam Jr. is a complex and difficult one. The novel raises questions about the nature of forgiveness, the conditions under which it is possible, and the potential benefits and drawbacks of extending forgiveness to others.
7.4 The Role of Authority
The novel examines the role of authority and the potential for authority figures to abuse their power. The judges and ministers in Salem use their authority to persecute innocent people, driven by their own fears and prejudices. The novel raises questions about the responsibility of authority figures to act justly and the importance of holding them accountable for their actions.
7.5 Social Justice
The novel also addresses broader issues of social justice, including the vulnerability of marginalized groups and the importance of protecting the rights of all individuals. The witch trials disproportionately targeted women, the poor, and those who were seen as outsiders. The novel raises questions about the responsibility of society to ensure equal treatment and protect the rights of vulnerable populations.
8. Connecting A Break with Charity to Contemporary Issues
The themes and issues explored in A Break with Charity remain relevant to contemporary society.
8.1 Mass Hysteria in the Digital Age
The phenomenon of mass hysteria is still prevalent today, particularly in the digital age. Social media and online platforms can amplify fear and misinformation, leading to the rapid spread of panic and irrational behavior. Understanding the dynamics of mass hysteria is crucial for navigating the complexities of the digital world.
8.2 The Ethics of Online Accusations
The novel’s exploration of the ethics of accusation is particularly relevant to online interactions. Social media platforms allow individuals to make accusations quickly and anonymously, often without regard for the consequences. The novel serves as a reminder of the importance of verifying information and considering the potential harm of online accusations.
8.3 The Importance of Critical Thinking
A Break with Charity underscores the importance of critical thinking and the need to question authority. The events in Salem demonstrate the dangers of blindly accepting information without careful analysis. The novel encourages readers to develop their critical thinking skills and to challenge assumptions and biases.
8.4 Social Responsibility in a Globalized World
The novel’s emphasis on social responsibility is particularly relevant in a globalized world. Individuals have a responsibility to act ethically and to speak out against injustice, both locally and globally. The novel encourages readers to consider their role in promoting social justice and protecting the rights of all people.
8.5 Lessons for Leadership
The novel provides valuable lessons for leadership, particularly in times of crisis. Leaders must be able to maintain reason and objectivity, to resist the pressure of mass hysteria, and to act justly and ethically. The novel serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of allowing fear and prejudice to influence decision-making.
9. Study Questions and Discussion Prompts
These study questions and discussion prompts can help you deepen your understanding of A Break with Charity.
- What are the main themes explored in A Break with Charity?
- How does Ann Rinaldi use literary devices to enhance the storytelling in the novel?
- What are the ethical considerations raised by the events in Salem?
- How does Susanna English evolve as a character throughout the novel?
- What role does fear play in the Salem Witch Trials?
- How does the novel connect to contemporary issues and challenges?
- What lessons can be learned from the events in A Break with Charity?
- How does the historical context of the Salem Witch Trials influence the events in the novel?
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of Susanna’s character?
- How does the novel portray the role of women in 17th-century Puritan society?
10. Resources for Further Learning
CONDUCT.EDU.VN offers a wealth of resources for further learning about the Salem Witch Trials and related topics.
- The Salem Witch Museum: Provides historical information and exhibits about the Salem Witch Trials.
- The Massachusetts Historical Society: Offers primary and secondary sources related to the history of Massachusetts.
- Books and Articles: Explore additional books and articles about the Salem Witch Trials and related topics.
FAQ: A Break With Charity Study Guide
Here are some frequently asked questions related to A Break With Charity and the Salem Witch Trials.
- What is the main message of A Break with Charity? The novel emphasizes the dangers of mass hysteria, the importance of social responsibility, and the power of truth.
- Who is Susanna English in A Break with Charity? Susanna is the protagonist of the novel, a young girl who becomes entangled in the events of the Salem Witch Trials.
- What is the historical context of A Break with Charity? The novel is set during the Salem Witch Trials of 1692, a period of intense fear and paranoia in colonial Massachusetts.
- What are the key themes in A Break with Charity? Key themes include mass hysteria, guilt and forgiveness, social responsibility, and the power of truth.
- How does Ann Rinaldi use literary devices in A Break with Charity? Rinaldi uses literary devices such as point of view, historical accuracy, symbolism, irony, and foreshadowing to enhance the storytelling.
- What ethical considerations are raised in A Break with Charity? Ethical considerations include the ethics of accusation, the ethics of silence, the ethics of forgiveness, and the role of authority.
- How does A Break with Charity connect to contemporary issues? The novel connects to contemporary issues such as mass hysteria in the digital age, the ethics of online accusations, and the importance of critical thinking.
- What is the significance of Ann Putnam Jr.’s apology at the end of the novel? The apology provides a sense of closure, but also raises questions about the nature of forgiveness and accountability.
- What role does religion play in A Break with Charity? Religion plays a significant role in the novel, as the Puritan beliefs and practices of the time contribute to the fear and paranoia that fuel the witch trials.
- How can A Break with Charity be used in the classroom? The novel can be used to teach students about history, literature, ethics, and social responsibility.
We at CONDUCT.EDU.VN aim to help you explore the depths of literature and understand the ethical dimensions of historical events. Our study guides are designed to provoke thought and promote a better understanding of the world around us.
Navigating the complexities of ethical standards and responsible behavior can be challenging. At CONDUCT.EDU.VN, we offer comprehensive guidelines and resources to help you understand and apply ethical principles in various situations. Visit our website at conduct.edu.vn or contact us at 100 Ethics Plaza, Guideline City, CA 90210, United States, or WhatsApp +1 (707) 555-1234, for more information.
