A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder has captivated audiences with its dark humor, witty lyrics, and inventive staging. This musical, about a charming young man who eliminates his relatives to inherit a fortune, has garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated following. Let’s delve into what makes this show so special, focusing on its unique theatrical elements and enduring appeal.
The journey of A Gentleman’s Guide began with the vision of Steven Lutvak and Robert Freedman, whose material immediately resonated with the creative team. The show, described as a “wicked comedy,” appealed to a sensibility that enjoys the “naughty” and the “subversive.” The story of Monty Navarro, who navigates love and murder with a dash of charm, promised an engaging theatrical experience. The director, drawn to the material’s dark humor and intricate plot, recognized the potential for a truly unique and entertaining show.
One of the most distinctive features of A Gentleman’s Guide is the casting of a single actor to play all eight of the doomed D’Ysquith family members. This bold choice transformed each murder into a theatrical reward, as audiences eagerly anticipated the actor’s next delightful characterization. The subversiveness of the show lies in the audience’s anticipation of the act of killing, knowing that the actor will return as another entertaining persona, be it Lady Salome or another unfortunate D’Ysquith. This approach makes the narrative less horrifying and more overtly theatrical. The fact that the D’Ysquith family members are generally awful people also helps to justify Monty’s actions in the eyes of the audience.
The theatricality of the production extends beyond the casting of the D’Ysquiths. A small ensemble cast of six actors takes on multiple roles, and a toy stage adds to the playful and inventive atmosphere. Each ensemble member has a “breakaway role,” allowing them to showcase their talents in memorable characters such as Lady Eugenia or the ill-fated ice skater, Miss Barley. This approach fosters a sense of ownership and camaraderie within the cast, enhancing the overall performance. The set and costume design further contribute to the show’s unique aesthetic, drawing inspiration from Edwardian toy theaters and incorporating clever projections. The creative team drew inspiration from classic films like Vertigo for the church tower scene, and the garden scene with the bees was inspired by the operettas of Jeanette MacDonald and Nelson Eddy.
The deaths of the D’Ysquiths are a highlight of the show, each more inventive and comical than the last. The creation of the “Poison in My Pocket” ice-skating scene exemplifies the collaborative spirit of the production. The initial idea of a Ferris wheel was scrapped in favor of something more dynamic and theatrical. Inspiration struck during a workshop when the director and Jefferson Mays, the actor playing the D’Ysquiths, improvised a skating routine, leading to the creation of the memorable ice-skating sequence. This scene highlights the show’s clever integration of music, choreography, and dark humor.
While Monty Navarro is the protagonist, he’s not necessarily the most likeable character. His ambition and talent for murder could easily make him a villain, but the show cleverly presents him as a complex figure. Comparing him to Tom Ripley, the protagonist of Patricia Highsmith’s novels, highlights the audience’s fascination with characters who get away with their crimes. The casting of a charismatic actor in the role of Monty is crucial to making him relatable and even sympathetic. Furthermore, the fact that the D’Ysquith family is largely unpleasant helps to justify Monty’s actions and makes him a more compelling protagonist.
Adding another layer of complexity to the story is the love triangle between Monty, the married Sibella, and Phoebe D’Ysquith. The actors were instructed to maintain a poker-faced demeanor, embodying the essence of English comedy, where secrets simmer beneath the surface of precise language. This understated approach adds to the show’s wit and charm.
The success of A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder on Broadway was a joyous experience for the entire team. The show’s blend of dark humor, inventive staging, and memorable performances resonated with audiences and critics alike, culminating in a Tony Award win. The enduring appeal of A Gentleman’s Guide is evident in its growing popularity among young people. The show has developed a cult following, with fans posting videos of themselves performing the songs and routines. Its sophisticated music and witty lyrics appeal to a new generation of musical theater enthusiasts, ensuring its continued success for years to come. The show requires a certain “Julie Andrews purity of singing,” and this attracts female performers.
