If you’re anything like me, you’ve been eagerly awaiting the TV adaptation of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. As a huge fan of the book series, I couldn’t wait to see how the story would translate to the screen. Finally, the series premiered on Netflix, and I immediately dove into episode one.
Before we proceed, be warned: this review will contain spoilers for both the TV show and the entire book series. If you haven’t read all the books, proceed with caution!
Now, let’s settle in and discuss A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, Episode 1.
Show Information: A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Episode 1 Length: 43:17
Content Warnings: Language, sexual violence, smoking, substances, death, murder, mentions of suicide, blood, grief
Episode Description: Pip decides to do her project on a local murder case. But when she starts her investigation, she learns some people would rather it was left in the past.
Setting the Tone
The first episode of any show is crucial, especially when adapting a beloved book. It sets the tone and provides a reference point for viewers familiar with the source material. This initial installment can either make or break the adaptation for fans. Fortunately, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Episode 1 successfully captured the essence of the book.
The opening sequence sent shivers down my spine. Starting with Andie walking down the street at night immediately establishes an ominous atmosphere. The close-up of the blood dripping down her hair is chilling and perfectly sets the stage for the mystery.
Adaptation vs. Original
I prefer to view adaptations as separate entities from the source material. Changes are inevitable, as what works on paper may not always translate well to the screen. However, the core integrity of the story should remain intact. While there were several changes from the book in this first episode, they didn’t detract from my enjoyment. I firmly believe that the show maintains the heart of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.
Emma Myers as Pip
Pip is a brilliant and determined character, and Emma Myers embodies her perfectly. She captures Pip’s intelligence, wit, and fierce protectiveness. Myers’ expressive face adds humor and charm to the character.
Flashbacks Enhance the Narrative
Flashbacks are a fantastic tool for adapting mystery stories. Since much of AGGGTM is told through mixed media and Pip’s perspective, the show utilizes flashbacks to provide a broader narrative. Seeing Andie and Sal’s sweet moments highlights the tragedy of their fate.
The flashback to young Pip seeing Andie in the school hallway adds another layer to Pip’s motivations. Andie signaling Pip to keep her whereabouts a secret, followed by Sal’s inquiry, creates a compelling reason for Pip to investigate. This was a clever storytelling decision by the screenwriter.
Pip and Ravi’s Meeting
My favorite scene in the first episode was Pip and Ravi’s initial encounter. The change of her trailing after him with Barney and the bribery muffins was great. Their easy banter instantly showcases their connection. Ravi remembering Pip from school and her calling him a “muffin genius” was adorable. Their first interaction perfectly captured the essence of Pip and Ravi as a team. Emma and Zain Iqbal (Ravi) delivered fantastic performances. Ravi’s carefree demeanor quickly shifts to a closed-off version of himself when Pip mentions her EPQ, highlighting the impact of Sal’s death. This subtle yet powerful portrayal solidified Zain’s suitability for the role.
Pacing and Plot Development
The plot moved quicker than expected, with Naomi revealing Sal had an alibi in the first episode. However, with only six episodes, the accelerated pacing is understandable. Viewers unfamiliar with the books likely won’t perceive the speed, as the episode flows well. A lot of ground was covered in the first episode and the storytelling was executed very well.
Little Loves of the Episode
- Pip and Cara holding hands as they walk
- Emma’s delivery of “I don’t want to be an accessory to a crime”
- “You dropped your communal brain cell” – I am Pippa Fitz-Amobi
- Pip turning her wall into a murder board and using Posca Pens (I think) directly onto the wall, iconic behavior
- Naomi’s unicorn sweatshirt
- Cara’s outfits in general
- The party costumes ⭐️
- Victor’s existence
Overall, the first episode of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder successfully sets the tone for the series. It was an enjoyable adaptation that left me excited to see how the rest of the season unfolds.
