This series presents an interesting mystery drama, but it struggles to firmly establish its identity. Despite its inconsistencies, the series offers several compelling elements, including captivating shooting locations, outstanding lead performances, a compelling mystery, and an almost cold-case-style investigation.
As someone who hasn’t read the book, I can’t compare its accuracy. However, some aspects feel familiar, and a few plot points, such as an accident reminiscent of “I Know What You Did Last Summer,” seem forced.
A recurring trope involves a tall, blonde young woman who conveniently appears whenever the protagonist requires assistance. While some friends receive adequate character development, others seem unnecessary. A noticeable pattern emerges: most white men are depicted as vile and criminal, while ethnic men are generally portrayed as kind and caring. This predictable portrayal feels like a weakness and detracts from the series.
While the casting is generally strong, one actor portraying a pressured 17-year-old appears significantly older. Smartphones are frequently used to advance the plot. The main character often delivers self-righteous speeches, while her Watson-like friend lacks a realistic life, often appearing aimlessly by a lake to facilitate conversations.
The series includes drug use and features untrustworthy figures in typically trusted professions, such as teachers and policemen. The plot suffers from significant holes, including an animal-related accident and unclear character motives. Despite some confusing elements, the overall storyline is generally easy to follow. The idealized setting, with perfect English cottages, traffic-free streets, and a well-behaved dog, feels somewhat artificial. The parents engage in witty banter, creating a TV-land atmosphere.
However, the compelling mystery and the series’ technical competence are commendable. Despite its flaws, the series explores relevant themes for young people, including racism, parenting, friendship, drugs, consent, and integrity. It touches on important subjects, making it more than just a good girl’s guide series free online for entertainment.
Overall, I rate it a 6 out of 10.
