“A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” series presents an intriguing, albeit uneven, mystery drama. While not flawless, the series has several redeeming qualities that make it worth considering for online viewing.
One of the most appealing aspects of the show is its visual charm. The shooting locations are undeniably lovely, providing a picturesque backdrop to the unfolding narrative. The lead performances are also noteworthy, with the actors delivering compelling portrayals of their respective characters. The central mystery itself is well-crafted, following a cold case investigation style that keeps viewers engaged.
The narrative, however, isn’t without its shortcomings. The series occasionally ventures into familiar territory, and certain plot points feel somewhat shoehorned in. For instance, an accident reminiscent of “I Know What You Did Last Summer” feels contrived. The convenient appearance of a tall blonde woman whenever the protagonist requires assistance also strains credibility. While some of the protagonist’s friends undergo development, others remain largely superfluous.
A noticeable pattern emerges in the series: white male characters are often portrayed as villains, engaging in vile and criminal behavior. In contrast, ethnic male characters are typically depicted as kind-hearted and caring. This thematic choice, while perhaps intended to make a statement, becomes repetitive and predictable. The casting choices also raise questions, as one actor portraying a pressured 17-year-old appears significantly older.
The series makes frequent use of smartphones, often employing them as a convenient plot device to advance the story. The main character frequently delivers self-righteous rants, while her companion seems to lack a realistic life, often appearing inexplicably by a lake to provide an opportunity for dialogue.
The series incorporates drug-related themes and portrays individuals in positions of trust, such as teachers and policemen, as untrustworthy. Furthermore, the plot contains significant holes, such as an animal accident with unclear motives. Despite these flaws, the overall narrative is generally easy to follow. The idealized portrayal of English cottage homes, traffic-free streets, and well-behaved pets contributes to a somewhat artificial “tv land” atmosphere.
Despite these drawbacks, the engaging mystery and the technically sound execution make the series enjoyable. The show also touches on relevant themes for young people, including racism, parenting, friendship, drugs, consent, and integrity.
In conclusion, “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” is a flawed but ultimately watchable series. The strong performances and engaging mystery are offset by predictable tropes and plot inconsistencies. If you enjoy mystery dramas and are willing to overlook its shortcomings, it may be worth watching online.
