“A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” presents an intriguing, though somewhat uneven, mystery that captivates with its setting, compelling lead performances, and cold-case investigation style. However, the series struggles to maintain consistency and occasionally veers into familiar territory, which can feel forced and detract from the overall experience.
The series boasts stunning shooting locations and strong performances from the leads. The central mystery and the investigation itself, reminiscent of a cold case, are genuinely engaging.
While the protagonist’s unwavering determination is admirable, the narrative sometimes falls into predictable patterns. The convenient appearance of a certain blonde woman whenever the main character needs assistance feels contrived. Similarly, while some of the protagonist’s friends experience character development, others remain underdeveloped and their contributions feel superficial.
The show’s portrayal of male characters also raises concerns. A pattern emerges where nearly all white men are depicted as villainous, often involved in criminal activities, while ethnic men are typically portrayed as kind and caring. This stark contrast feels like an overused trope.
The casting is generally well-executed. Smartphones play a significant role in advancing the plot. The main character often delivers self-righteous speeches. Her companion, however, seems to exist solely to provide a sounding board, appearing in convenient locations for the protagonist to confide in.
The series incorporates drug use and portrays professionals such as teachers and police officers as untrustworthy. Several plot holes exist, including an illogical accident involving an animal and unclear character motivations.
Despite these shortcomings, the series is technically well-made and maintains a steady pace. It touches on themes relevant to young adults, including racism, parenting, friendship, drugs, consent, and integrity. The idealized depiction of English cottage homes, traffic-free streets, and well-behaved pets contributes to a somewhat artificial “TV land” atmosphere.
Ultimately, the appeal of “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” lies in its captivating mystery and exploration of relevant themes. However, inconsistencies and plot holes detract from the overall experience. Despite its flaws, the series offers enough intrigue and entertainment to warrant a viewing.
The show contains mature themes and some potentially disturbing content, so it is generally recommended for viewers aged 16 and older. While there is no official “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” rating age specified, this guideline ensures a more mature audience is consuming the content.
