This mystery drama series presents an interesting, though somewhat uneven, viewing experience. While it boasts attractive shooting locations, compelling lead performances, and an intriguing central mystery framed as a cold case investigation, it struggles to maintain a firm footing throughout its run. As someone who hasn’t read the source material, I cannot comment on its fidelity to the original book.
The series occasionally veers into familiar territory, and certain plot points feel forced, including an accident reminiscent of “I Know What You Did Last Summer.” A particular blonde character seems to materialize conveniently whenever the protagonist requires assistance. While some of the friends receive adequate development, others feel largely superfluous. A recurring trope emerges wherein virtually all the white male characters are depicted as villains, often engaging in despicable criminal behavior. Conversely, ethnic male characters are primarily portrayed as kind and caring, a stark contrast that feels heavy-handed. This type of characterization is becoming an overused and predictable trope. Despite this, the casting is generally strong, although one actor portraying a stressed 17-year-old looks considerably older. Smartphones are frequently utilized to advance the plot, but in a slightly unnatural way. The main character delivers numerous self-righteous speeches, while her sidekick inexplicably lacks a realistic life, often appearing randomly for the protagonist to confide in him.
The series incorporates a substantial amount of drug-related content, and presents an unsettling portrayal of trusted professions, such as teachers and policemen, as being far from trustworthy. The plot also contains some gigantic holes, specifically involving an animal-related accident that defies logic, as well as some of the characters’ motives. Although some aspects remain unclear, the overall narrative is generally comprehensible.
The show also presents an idealized vision of English life, with perfect cottage homes, traffic-free streets, and a dog that never barks, causes messes, or creates problems. The parents engage in witty banter, contributing to a somewhat artificial television landscape. Despite these flaws, the mystery element is engaging, and the pacing is well-maintained. Technically, the series is well-executed, earning it an overall rating of 6.
Despite its occasionally humorous characterizations, the series is not a comedy, and it touches on important themes relevant to young people, including racism, parenting, friendship, drugs, consent, and integrity. The show’s exploration of these themes is a key element of its appeal and makes it more than just a simple whodunit. The investigation itself keeps you guessing, and the performances, particularly that of the lead actress, are compelling. While it may not be a perfect show, “a good girl’s guide to murder watch” offers a worthwhile viewing experience, especially for those who enjoy a thought-provoking mystery. The exploration of timely social issues adds depth to the plot, making it more than just a simple teenage drama.
