This review delves into the second standalone novel in the “A Lady’s Guide” historical romance series, examining its strengths, weaknesses, and overall appeal. If you’re considering downloading A Lady’s Guide to Scandal epub, read on to discover if this is the right book for you.
Story Synopsis:
Set in 1819, the story follows twenty-eight-year-old Eliza, a widow who feels more relieved than saddened by the death of her much older husband. Trapped by societal expectations, Eliza seeks respite in Bath with her cousin Margaret. There, she attempts to experience a freer life, albeit within the constraints of widowhood. However, her “scandalous behavior” reaches her family, highlighting the limited freedom afforded to women, even in mourning. The narrative unfolds from Eliza’s limited third-person perspective.
This book follows “A Lady’s Guide to Fortune-Hunting.” While the books are stand-alone, a reference to Lord Radcliffe is made. The settings and storylines differ, allowing readers to enjoy them in any sequence.
The “Yays”: What Works Well in A Lady’s Guide to Scandal:
👌 Social Commentary: While adhering to genre conventions, the story subtly critiques the rigid social norms of historical England. The countless rules governing women’s behavior are presented almost satirically. The novel also addresses prejudices against outsiders and biracial individuals, the patriarchal laws that disempowered women, and the relentless pursuit of social advancement.
👌 Melville’s Character: Melville stands out as an unconventional historical romance hero due to his biracial heritage (Indian mother). His portrayal is appreciated because his Indian background feels integral to his character, rather than being used merely for exoticism.
👌 Eliza’s Artistic Talent: Eliza’s artistry is genuinely integrated into the plot. The story explores the societal limitations placed upon female artists, including restrictions on the types of paints they could use.
👌 Fun Banter: Enjoyable moments of witty conversation and playful exchanges occur between characters, particularly between Eliza and Margaret, and Eliza and Melville.
👌 Setting in Bath: The writing effectively utilizes the attractions of Bath, a popular destination during that era, as a backdrop for the story.
Mixed Feelings: Areas with Room for Improvement:
⚠ Eliza’s Character Arc: While Kitty from the first book sought financial security, Eliza desires freedom. Her character effectively illustrates the emotional manipulation she endured in the past and her newfound desire for autonomy. However, some of Eliza’s decisions feel questionable, and her abrupt change in affection after committing to one man is jarring.
⚠ “Persuasion” Parallels: The first book paid homage to Jane Austen’s “Pride & Prejudice.” This book is intended to echo “Persuasion,” but the connection feels tenuous beyond a few elements like a returning old flame. As a modernized, feminized version of “Persuasion,” it falls short.
⚠ LGBTQ+ Representation: The inclusion of an LGBTQ+ couple later in the story is predictable. Their portrayal feels somewhat anachronistic, lacking the challenges and complexities of same-sex relationships in the 1810s. Eliza’s initial acceptance is surprisingly nonchalant. However, the couple is endearing and adds to the story.
⚠ Rushed Ending: The ending is satisfying, offering a hopeful conclusion. However, the resolution feels rushed, with issues being resolved too quickly compared to the more leisurely pace of the rest of the plot.
The “Nays”: What Didn’t Quite Work:
👎 Boring Love Triangle: The love triangle lacks tension and suspense, making it predictable from the outset. It’s clear who Eliza will choose, diminishing the intrigue.
👎 Weak Connection with Somerset: The connection between Eliza and Somerset, despite their long history, feels unconvincing. Their relationship, both past and present, seems flimsy.
👎 Stereotypical Characters: Most of the characters, with the exception of Lady Caroline and Margaret, are stereotypical and lack depth.
👎 Repetitive Thoughts: Eliza’s internal monologues become repetitive, particularly when she is conflicted about her feelings.
Overall:
A Lady’s Guide to Scandal epub provides mindless entertainment within the historical romance genre. If you’re seeking a lighthearted read without overthinking, you might enjoy it. However, it pales in comparison to the first book in the series. Consider downloading A Lady’s Guide to Scandal epub if you enjoy “Bridgerton”-esque modernized historical romances.
Final Verdict:
3.25 stars.
