“A Practical Guide to Evil” is a web serial by ErraticErrata that has garnered a dedicated following for its intricate world-building, morally grey characters, and subversion of classic fantasy tropes. This is A Practical Guide To Evil Review, delving into the story’s strengths, weaknesses, and overall appeal.
The story follows Catherine Foundling, an orphan in the war-torn land of Calernia, who joins the armies of the Evil Empire of Praes. Instead of becoming a hero, she chooses the path of a villain, aiming to climb the ranks and shape the world according to her own vision.
A World Built on Narrative
One of the most striking aspects of “A Practical Guide to Evil” is its meta-narrative approach. The world operates according to established narrative rules and tropes. Characters are aware of these tropes and often manipulate them to their advantage. This creates a fascinating dynamic where strategy and understanding of narrative conventions are as important as brute force.
“You know, one is understandable,” I said. “Happens to the best of us. But two? That’s just careless, Hakram. It’s not like you have any more spares.”“I suppose my clapping days are over,” Adjutant thoughtfully replied. “And I never did take to the theatre.”There was a pause.“You made the same damned joke the last time you lost a hand, didn’t you?” I sighed.“It’s funnier this time,” he told me. “You know, because I’m running out of hands to lose.”
The setting of Calernia is richly detailed, with a complex history, diverse cultures, and warring factions. The author expertly weaves political intrigue, military strategy, and magical elements into a cohesive and engaging narrative. The magic system, based on Names and Aspects, is unique and well-defined, adding another layer of depth to the world.
Morally Grey Characters
“A Practical Guide to Evil” excels at creating compelling characters with complex motivations. Catherine Foundling is a particularly intriguing protagonist. While she chooses the path of evil, her actions are often driven by a desire to protect the innocent and create a better world, even if it means making difficult choices and sacrificing her own morality.
The supporting cast is equally well-developed, with each character possessing their own unique personality, motivations, and backstory. From the loyal and pragmatic orc Adjutant Hakram to the cunning and ambitious Diabolist Akua, the characters in “A Practical Guide to Evil” are far from one-dimensional.
“Cat, did you pull a knife on goddesses?” Adjutant sighed.“Of course not,” I replied, offended and technically even saying the truth.The orc stared at me, saying nothing.“We have an understanding,” I said, a tad defensively. “You wouldn’t understand, you’re not religious.”“I’m not going to touch that without a bottle on the table and half a day to waste,” Hakram muttered.
The relationships between the characters are complex and often fraught with tension. Alliances shift, betrayals occur, and friendships are tested, creating a dynamic and unpredictable narrative.
Strengths and Weaknesses
One of the greatest strengths of “A Practical Guide to Evil” is its intricate plot. The story is full of twists and turns, and the author expertly subverts expectations. The pacing is generally well-managed, although some arcs can feel slower than others. As one of the quotes from the provided text said:
Amazing as usual, though a good chunk of the last few chapters were a bit difficult to get through due to slow politics and lack of action.
The sheer length of the series can be daunting for new readers, and the complex world-building may require some initial investment to fully grasp. However, the rewards are well worth the effort.
Another potential weakness is the occasional reliance on exposition. While the author does a good job of conveying information, some readers may find the infodumps disruptive to the flow of the narrative.
Overall Appeal
“A Practical Guide to Evil” is a must-read for fans of grimdark fantasy and stories that challenge traditional notions of good and evil. Its intricate world-building, morally grey characters, and meta-narrative approach make it a unique and engaging read. While the length and complexity of the series may be intimidating to some, the rewards are well worth the investment.
The story’s exploration of power, morality, and the consequences of choices resonates deeply, making it a thought-provoking and unforgettable experience. If you’re looking for a fantasy epic that subverts expectations and challenges your perceptions, “A Practical Guide to Evil” is an excellent choice.
