Embark on a journey through the vast universe of Lily and James Potter fanfiction. Like stars in the night sky, these stories offer guidance and direction for every fan seeking tales of love, laughter, and adventure in the Marauders era. Whether you’re a seasoned reader or new to the fandom, “All Of These Stars Will Guide Us Home” to the perfect story. This curated list highlights some of the most brilliant and beloved fics, categorized for your exploration. Let’s dive in and discover your next favorite read!
Fandom Famous Fics: The Brightest Stars
These stories have achieved legendary status within the Lily and James fandom. They are often recommended, widely discussed, and considered essential reading for anyone interested in this pairing.
Timeless Classics
Commentarius by B.C Daily. *
Follow Lily Evans in her seventh year as she navigates the complexities of being Head Girl, the confusing behavior of her friends, and the persistent charm of a certain James Potter she can’t quite shake off. This fic beautifully portrays Lily’s journey of self-discovery and unexpected romance.
The Life and Times by Jewels5.
Experience the dynamic and often argumentative relationship between Lily and James. This story meticulously builds their connection, showcasing their contrasting personalities and the slow burn of their undeniable chemistry. It’s a testament to the idea that matters of the heart truly require time.
Iconic Series
The Boyfriend trilogy (Boyfriend, Fiancée and Pregnant) by Molly Raesly.
Dive into the hilarious and heartwarming journey of Lily and James’ relationship as it evolves from a fake boyfriend scenario to engagements and parenthood. This trilogy is filled with witty banter, relatable characters, and the delightful awkwardness of early love.
Enemies to Lovers
Buried Treasure and Transmogrify by RiennaHawks
Witness the classic enemies-to-lovers trope unfold as Head Boy James Potter and Head Girl Lily Evans are forced to work together. Preconceived notions are challenged, and they both discover that their initial judgments might have been completely wrong.
Letters by GhostOfBambi. *
Escape into a summer where Lily Evans, feeling abandoned and tormented, finds unexpected solace and connection through letters with James Potter. This story beautifully captures the development of their feelings amidst personal turmoil.
Short & Sweet
100 stories of Lily and James by Witblogi.
Enjoy a delightful collection of 100 drabbles, each exploring a different moment in James and Lily’s lives. This fic offers a diverse range of scenarios and themes, perfect for quick and charming reads.
A Month of Sundays by Marzipan. *
Relive the pivotal moments in fifth year when Lily begins to understand her true feelings for James Potter after ending her friendship with Snape. This story is a poignant exploration of buried emotions and the awakening of love.
Sixth Year Drama
Prelude to Destiny by brainchild.
Experience the rollercoaster of Lily’s sixth year as she grapples with an unwanted crush on James Potter and the chaos that ensues when her ex-boyfriend reappears. This fic is packed with teenage drama, romantic tension, and spiraling events.
Humorous & Quirky
Obsessive Lily Disorder by Procrastinator-starting2morro.
Prepare for a humorous and exaggerated take on James’s infatuation with Lily. This fic includes stalking antics, Polyjuice potion mishaps, and James’s comical attempts to win Lily’s affection, questioning whether her dislike is genuine.
Multi-Chapter Fics: Extended Constellations
For readers who prefer longer narratives and deeper dives into the Lily and James universe, these multi-chapter fics offer expansive storylines and intricate character development.
Body Swap Shenanigans
A different view on Love by Merlinhelz. *
Laugh along as Lily and James find themselves in each other’s bodies after a potions accident. This fic is a hilarious exploration of their personalities clashing and merging, forcing them to see the world – and each other – from a completely new perspective.
Forced Proximity & Slow Burn Romance
The Muggleborn Protection Act by e.demitria.
In a world threatened by Voldemort, Lily is placed under the protection of a pureblood family – the Potters. Can she navigate living as a “Potter” and resist falling for her charming yet infuriating “brother,” James?
If I fell by anAnomaLy.
Seventh year throws Lily Evans for a loop as she finds herself working closely with James Potter as Head Boy and Girl. Unexpectedly, she begins to fall for the mischievous young man she once despised.
Kiss and Tell by SunshineDaisiesWindmills.
Intrigue and attraction ignite as Lily and James engage in a game of provocation, screams, and secret kisses. The only rule? Never kiss and tell.
You Don’t Say by UndercoverFabala.
Explore the complexities of James Potter as Lily sees both his swoon-worthy charm and his frustrating flaws. This fic delves into the tricky balance of liking someone who can be both wonderful and infuriating.
Angst & Emotional Depth
I’ll fight for you by Hazelmist.
Experience the raw emotion as James confronts Lily about her repeated rejections. Lily reveals her fear of being hurt by his selfish nature, highlighting the vulnerability beneath their dynamic.
Unrivaled by TheKat1.
Witness the intense rivalry between James and Lily escalate into hatred when things get complicated. This story explores the thin line between love and hate, and the passion that fuels both.
Married Life & Flashbacks
The Art of Successfully Dating a Quidditch Player by DisorderlyandPunk.
Join a married Lily and James, expecting their first child, as a trip to Diagon Alley sparks fond memories of their courtship. This fic offers a heartwarming glimpse into their established love story through nostalgic flashbacks.
Challenges & Games
One of them by ScarlettSunshine.
Lily takes on a challenge: keeping up with the Marauders for a week. This fic is filled with the chaotic energy of teenage boys and the budding romance that blossoms when Lily joins their world.
Missed Opportunities & Second Chances
Inability to Act by GhostOfBambi. *
Reflect on the “what ifs” and missed chances in this poignant story about taking risks and speaking your heart. It’s a tale for anyone who has ever wished they had done things differently.
Diary Entries & School Secrets
Scribblings of a Red Head and a Quidditch Captain by CasablancaInTheTardis.
Harry Potter discovers his parents’ diaries, revealing the secrets of how Head Girl Lily and Quidditch Captain James finally fell in love. This fic offers a charming glimpse into their school days through their personal writings.
Unexpected Summer Romance
And Thats When a Bludger Came Through My Window by Jen Riddle.
Lily’s peaceful summer at her aunt’s cottage is disrupted by a bludger – and James Potter. This fic is a lighthearted summer romance with a touch of magical chaos.
The Fic About Nothing (Hilariously So)
Haggis from Algernon by Rude Gus.
Experience the wonderfully absurd and pointless adventures in “the fic about nothing.” Perfect for readers who enjoy quirky humor and unconventional storytelling.
Sirius Black’s Meddling
Joined at the hip by Livelier.
After six years of James’s unsuccessful attempts to woo Lily, Sirius Black takes matters into his own hands. Expect hilarious chaos and unexpected outcomes in this story of friendship and matchmaking.
One-Shot Wonders: Sparkling Nebulae
These concise and impactful one-shot stories deliver satisfying narratives within a single chapter, perfect for a quick dose of Lily and James romance.
Secret Admirers & Misdelivered Letters
Yours, Ivan by Procrastinator-Starting2moro.
James makes a surprising discovery when he reads a letter addressed to “Lily Evans” from a Bulgarian boy. This fic explores hidden feelings and the revelations that can come from unexpected places.
Pub Encounters & Milestone Moments
Scenes from a Hogsmead Pub by B.C Daily. *
Witness five significant scenes in Lily and James’ relationship, all set within the cozy atmosphere of The Three Broomsticks pub. This fic captures key moments in their developing romance.
Lamps, Chaos, and Snogging
In Illuminated Symbollic Glory by charmingly-holly.
A lamp, a thrown object, and a series of chaotic events lead to unexpected snogging in this humorous and quirky one-shot. It’s a testament to how destiny can be found in the most unlikely of circumstances.
Lunchtime Negotiations & Realizations
Realising by B.C Daily.
James’s struggles to even get Lily to agree to lunch highlight his realization that being Head Boy doesn’t necessarily make winning Lily over any easier. This fic is a funny and insightful look at their dynamic.
Love in Wartime
Recipies of Disaster by robb-starks.
Even amidst war, love can blossom. This fic reminds us that even in the darkest times, Lily and James find each other.
Hijacked Moments & Inappropriate Locales
Hijacking by B.C Daily.
Lily and James’s playful hijacking of each other’s prefect duties leads to secret rendezvous in entirely inappropriate Hogwarts locations. This fic is a steamy and mischievous exploration of their attraction.
Shirtless Distractions in the Library
The Incident in the Library by greenconverses.
Lily’s library focus is completely derailed by James Potter and his distracting, unbuttoned shirt. This fic is a light and fluffy, yet subtly sensual, seventh-year tale.
Couples Therapy with McGonagall
Couples Therapy by GhostOfBambi.
Minerva McGonagall, in her many roles, takes on the challenge of couples therapy for Lily and James. This fic offers a humorous and insightful look at their relationship through a therapeutic lens.
Childhood Dreams & Letting Go
Our Last Days as Children by herbeautifullie.
Explore the bittersweet feeling of letting go of childhood dreams as they become reality. This fic is a poignant reflection on growing up and embracing the future.
Hugs as Defense Mechanisms
Have you hugged your James Potter today? by Procrastinator-starting2morro.
Discover the humorous strategy of using hugs to keep James Potter at bay in this lighthearted one-shot.
Christmas Tart Chaos
Boiling the Tarts by B.C Daily. *
Christmas tart making turns chaotic when James decides to boil his dough in the fireplace, much to Lily’s dismay. This fic is a funny and festive holiday mishap.
Confessions Overheard by the Fat Lady
He wasn’t all bad by Amelia Bedelia.
The Fat Lady recounts a story of overhearing James’s heartfelt confession to Lily, offering a glimpse into his softer side and challenging preconceived notions about him.
Alternative Universes: Parallel Galaxies
Explore Lily and James in entirely different settings and scenarios, offering fresh perspectives on their relationship.
1940s Boarding School & Wartime Love
Petal in the Rain by pratty-prongs-princesse.
In 1940s England during the Battle of Britain, Lily escapes her snobbish boarding school and encounters Lord James Potter. This fic blends love, war, magic, and deception in a historical AU.
Pirates & Dukes’ Daughters
Wind and Waves by HeroOfTheCastleOfMarble.
Captain James Potter, a pirate, and Lily, a Duke’s daughter, strike a contract that leads her onto his pirate ship. This fic is a swashbuckling adventure with romance on the high seas.
What If Lily Loved James First?
As Told by Lily by avantika.
This diary-style fic flips the usual dynamic, exploring a scenario where Lily loves James, but James hates Lily. It offers a unique and intriguing twist on their classic story.
Marriage Proposals & Second Chances
The Bewitchment of James Potter by Luna_Elentari.
After Lily rejects James’s marriage proposal in seventh year, opportunity knocks again three years later. This fic explores second chances and the enduring nature of love.
Titanic Romance & Class Differences
Nothing on Earth by greenconverses.
Set aboard the RMS Titanic, Lily, wealthy and engaged, falls for James, a street urchin. This fic is a dramatic and romantic retelling of their love story against the backdrop of the famous tragedy.
Rockstar AU & Hidden Identities
Starstruck by Seven Scribbles.
Lily’s summer takes an unexpected turn when she discovers the Marauders, England’s biggest band, hiding in her barn. This fic blends rockstar fame, unwanted attention, and hidden dangers with Lily and James’s connection.
As you navigate these stellar fanfictions, remember that “all of these stars will guide us home”—home to heartwarming stories, captivating characters, and the enduring magic of Lily and James. Happy reading!
