Persona 5 Royal Negotiation Guide offers an exhaustive walkthrough of shadow negotiation. Mastering persona negotiation is crucial for recruiting powerful allies and succeeding in the game’s complex social dynamics. conduct.edu.vn provides insights and resources to help you navigate the intricacies of Persona 5 Royal.
1. Understanding Persona 5 Royal Negotiation Mechanics
Negotiation in Persona 5 Royal is a key mechanic for recruiting new Personas. Unlike traditional RPGs where you simply defeat enemies to gain them, Persona 5 Royal requires you to engage in conversations with Shadows to convince them to join your team. This involves understanding their personalities and responding to their questions in a way that appeals to them.
1.1. Shadow Personalities
Shadows in Persona 5 Royal have one of four basic personality types: Gloomy, Irritable, Timid, and Upbeat. Each personality type reacts differently to your responses during negotiation. Understanding these personalities is the first step to successfully recruiting Personas.
- Gloomy: These Shadows are often pessimistic and respond well to answers that acknowledge their feelings or offer a different perspective.
- Irritable: Irritable Shadows are easily annoyed and prefer direct, confident answers. Avoid being submissive or uncertain with them.
- Timid: Timid Shadows are insecure and appreciate reassurance and support. Positive and encouraging responses work best.
- Upbeat: Upbeat Shadows are cheerful and energetic, so they respond well to humorous and lighthearted answers.
1.2. The Negotiation Process
When you knock down all enemies in a battle, you have the option to initiate a Hold Up. This allows you to either demand items, money, or attempt to negotiate with the Shadows. If you choose to negotiate, the Shadows will ask you a series of questions or make demands. Your responses will determine whether they become interested in joining you, give you items, or become angry and attack.
1.3. Key Stats and Skills
Several stats and skills can influence your negotiation success:
- Charm: A high Charm stat increases your chances of successfully negotiating with Shadows.
- Skills: Certain skills, such as those learned from Confidants, can provide additional advantages during negotiation. For instance, some skills allow you to retry negotiations or automatically succeed in certain situations.
2. Mastering Shadow Negotiation: A Detailed Guide
To effectively negotiate with Shadows, it’s essential to understand how each personality type reacts to different responses. This section provides a comprehensive guide to navigating various scenarios and questions.
2.1. General Negotiation Tips
Before diving into specific questions, here are some general tips to keep in mind:
- Save Before Negotiating: If you’re attempting to recruit a specific Persona, save your game before initiating the negotiation. This allows you to reload if things go wrong.
- Observe Shadow Reactions: Pay attention to the Shadows’ reactions after each response. Their body language and dialogue can provide clues about whether you’re on the right track.
- Use Persona Skills: Utilize Persona skills that boost negotiation success or provide additional options during conversations.
2.2. Detailed Question and Answer Guide
Below is an extensive list of questions Shadows might ask, categorized by their personality type, along with the best responses for each. This guide is designed to help you navigate even the trickiest negotiations.
2.2.1 Gloomy Shadows
| Question | Best Response(s) |
|---|---|
| A bad rep spreads like wildfire. If I were you, I’d quit all this nonsense. What’s the point? | I don’t know any other way. |
| After confronting me like this… Are you that kind of human too? | What’s wrong with that? |
| Ah, it’s a shame. If I’d taken this seriously from the start, I wouldn’t be in this sorry state. | Then get serious now. |
| Ah, so I suppose you commit such extreme acts because you know you won’t be punished harshly… | This isn’t extreme. |
| And if that’s the case, why don’t you just stop this futile endeavor? It’s meaningless… | I can’t stop. |
| Aren’t people as old as you s’posed to go “dating,” all the time? Can’t you get some dates? | Dating’s not important. |
| As far as you’re concerned, what kind of person was I to you? | It doesn’t matter. |
| But I’ve been around the block, so I know–there’s something else you want from me, isn’t there? | I just want you to die happy. |
| But what if I ripped your body apart? …What color blood would come pouring out? | I never bleed or cry. |
| Can you sacrifice yourself in order to demonstrate your adoration of our Father? | I don’t adore him. |
| Care to explain yourself? I certainly hope you have a good reason for this boorish treatment. | It’d take a while to explain. |
| Couldn’t you at least make me a cup of tea or somethin’? Hell, that’d be real polite. | I’m not hospitable. |
| Did I just see your hand shaking? Are you OK? | I’m a little scared… |
| Didn’t you feel like that when you were a kid, too? | I don’t remember. |
| Do you have a lot of friends? Ever feel like the things they do are annoying? | I have no friends. |
| Don’t you think expecting your would-be victim to be receptive to your words is unreasonable? | I don’t think its unfair. |
| Guess what I want you to read to me before you tuck me into bed! | Ask someone else. |
| Heed my words. I am not the one you should detest. | That’s absurd. |
| Hell, I got all sorta girls lined up if you’re into that. | Really? |
| Hey, how about this? If you don’t shoot me, then I’ll kiss you. Not a bad deal, right? | I don’t want a kiss. |
| Hey, if you got any medicine, lend me some. They’re supposed ta work miracles, right…? | What kind of medicine? |
| Hey, let’s play a game! Guess what I wanna eat! | Curry. |
| Hey mister, if I grew up, what do you think the future me would’ve been like? | Living in the darkness. |
| Hey, mister, will you give me a yummy snack to eat? | Later. |
| Hey. So whaddya think when you think about the future? | An average level of happiness. |
| Hey, sonny if somethin’s been botherin’ you. I’m willing to give you a listen. | My relationships… |
| How ’bout you? You wanna get married someday? | I don’t. |
| How can you do such terrible things to a cute hee-ho like me!? | Now that you mention it… |
| How did I lose to you? I mean… I win when it comes to looks, ho. | I worked hard. |
| Humans always want either an autograph or a self-hee, ho. Which is it, ho? | I want a photo. |
| I also have loved ones who would miss me. You do catch my meaning, yes? | I’m always alone. |
| I coulda been a star… | Are you giving up? |
| I don’t hate you. No, I don’t feel that way at all… | Is that so? |
| I fear neither death… nor you. | Why are you telling me this? |
| I guess women are really more social these days, finding so many fun things to do outside. | It’s the women’s fault. |
| I know when I’m gettin’ all sweaty. I’m glistenin’, ain’t I? | Why does that matter? |
| I mean, how does it feel to wave your gun at an enemy who’s completely lost the will to fight? | It pains my heart… |
| I occasionally wish to pamper myself as a reward for working hard. How would you do that? | Don’t be so selfish. |
| I suppose that’s why I feel so confused, child. After all, why am I being treated like this? | It can’t be helped. |
| I suppose this “real world” where you come from must be fairly boring. | I’m always so busy there. |
| I think dying alone isn’t so bad dearie, but isn’t living alone in the first place the real tragedy? | Being alone is a luxury. |
| I wish I could see what kind of parents raised you to run loose and wreak havoc like this. | Leave my parents out of this. |
| I wonder how things might have been between us if circumstances had been different somehow? | Nothing would’ve changed. |
| I wonder if us speaking together like this now means that we are somehow connected… | No, I don’t think so. |
| If I’d known things would end like this, I wish I had found the courage to ask that girl out… | You never had a chance. |
| I’ll let you kill me, but first I want you to do something fun for me before that. | Ask someone else. |
| In the very end, what the hell are you tryin’ ta tell me? | I don’t really know… |
| Is it not possible for this series of events involving you and me to be attributed to that? | That is incorrect. |
| Is there really any benefit for me if I joined with you? | I think there is. |
| Isn’t that just like when a human woman gets married and moves in with her husband? | I love someone else. |
| It look like you corner me… But how me know this not trick? How me know you really winning? | Don’t try to escape reality. |
| It’s cliched, but we could chat about life… Ask each other things like what kind of girls we like… | I like older women. |
| It’s hard to tell under the mask, but… you’re actually handsome, aren’t you? | I look ok, I guess. |
| I’ve been sending you serious “don’t speak to me” vibes. | I noticed. |
| Just thinkin’ about hierarchy, you should be showin’ me a little more respect, shouldn’t you? | You’re right, Senpai. |
| Know how they say, “Be kind ta yer elders”? Has no one ever taught you that? | I don’t want to grow old. |
| Me guessing you have power that me not have. But what is it…? | Girl power. |
| Maybe I should try something new! I don’t want to fall into mediocrity, ho… | It’s fine as is. |
| Now, people don’t even know who lives next door to them. Shouldn’t we know our neighbors better? | It’s saddening. |
| Oh, they’re so self-assured that they’ll be so successful in the future. Are you like that, child? | That’s not true. |
| Seriously, cosplaying in a place like this? Are you just really freakin’ bored? | I am. |
| Taking that into consideration, do you still want me? | That’s right. |
| That power, vow that you will use it in the name of our Father. | That’s a bit much. |
| That’s wack, man. Maybe you should get your head checked out. | I probably should. |
| The way you treat me, though, is giving me mixed messages. How do you really feel about me? | You’re beautiful. |
| Therefore, I cannot be destroyed. Desist from this pointlessness. | That’s absurd. |
| They always give the guys katsudon! You got anything like that for me!? | I have nothing for you. |
| They wear sleeveless shirts in the winter, right? What do you think about that, dearie? | I don’t care. |
| This is all some kind of thing for the TV, ho! Where’s the camera? | What’s all this now? |
| To view me as an enemy is to incur our Father’s wrath. Man’s future rests in your hands. | What are you trying to say? |
| Um, this has been buggin’ me for a while, but… Is it me, or does something stink? | It’s just you. |
| Very well. In the place of our Father, I shall listen to your complaints. | Why can’t we end war? |
| We’ll just say you win. So can we stop this? | We can say you won. |
| Well, quite frankly… No one wants you here. You do understand that, right? | I didn’t know that. |
| What did you want, coming all the way to a place like this? | A treasure hunt. |
| What do ya usually eat? | Curry. |
| What if I was a “human”? Then, what you’re doing… Well, it’d be a criminal act! | That’s unrelated. |
| What kinda “fate” do you think there is in this meetin’ between me and you? | There is no such thing. |
| What you thinking now? | I want girls to like me. |
| What’re you gonna tell your kids about this shit? | I’ll forget it happened. |
| When I was young, I could make anyone back off – if they were smart enough – with just my glare. | Fights are just luck. |
| When you were little, what did you wanna be when you grow up? | A winner in society. |
| Where do babies come from? | The love between two people. |
| Why are you so interested in me, anyway? | I’ve got enough on my plate… |
| Why did you come to such a dangerous place? Isn’t it much safer in the real world? | There are things I must do. |
| Why do they like “making out”? | How should I know? |
| Why you come all the way here? | I’m here to find myself. |
| Why you fight and put yourself in harm’s way? | I don’t actually know. |
| Why you keep trampling here? What you humans thinking? | I haven’t thought about it. |
| Why you not care for me like that? Why you treat me like this, then? | You look terrifying. |
| Why you wear mask to fight, anyway? | That’s what I want to know. |
| Why’re you so desperate? | I don’t want to die. |
| Would you do to anyone what you’re doing to me now? | No, I wouldn’t. |
| Wouldn’t your girlfriend get jealous if she could see us? | I don’t have a girlfriend. |
| Y’know, if I’m gonna be killed, I’d rather be offed by some beautiful, classy woman. | You don’t get to be picky. |
| You do know that just pointing that at someone doesn’t actually do anything, right? Buffoon. | I know. |
| You do understand that I’m here because people like you exist, right? | Eh, doesn’t matter. |
| You go back to your mother’ arms. You need take nap now. | I’m not sleepy yet. |
| You have appeared to test my adoration of our Father. Yes, you are… the Tempter! | You’re mistaken. |
| You have wishes you can not let go of, even after you die? | I don’t plan on dying. |
| You, however are talking to me right here. Are you the exception to this rule? | I’m not special. |
| You’re a big bully! don’t you think that’s “immature”? | No, I don’t think so. |
| You’re lucky it was just me. You can’t do anything like this in the real world, right? | That’s right. |
| You’re s’posed to go easy on kids! Are you stupid? Do you go to school and get stupid grades? | Shut up. |
| You’ve come from some other company to scout me-hee out. There’s no mistaking it, ho! | It’s a misunderstanding. |
2.2.2 Irritable Shadows
| Question | Best Response(s) |
|---|---|
| A bad rep spreads like wildfire. If I were you, I’d quit all this nonsense. What’s the point? | I don’t care. |
| Are you bored? | Yes, I’m bored. |
| Aren’t people as old as you s’posed to go “dating,” all the time? Can’t you get some dates? | Such a rude little boy… |
| As far as you’re concerned, what kind of person was I to you? | My rival. |
| But is it fair to the others if I find this happiness, leaving them all in the dust? | What’s wrong with that? |
| But what if I ripped your body apart? …What color blood would come pouring out? | Red. |
| Confess your sins. | No chance. |
| Did I just see your hand shaking? Are you OK? | Shut up |
| Did I lose…? | What don’t you get? |
| Don’t take this the wrong way, but man… Bein’ a carefree kid sure must be nice. | I prefer being an adult. |
| How ’bout you, sonny? What kinda trip do you wanna take? | A trip to hell. |
| How did you find out about me, ho? | Some flyers. |
| I can’t sadden my fans, ho. …You catch my drift, don’t you? | Tell me. |
| I gotta ask. How do you train? | I don’t really train. |
| I insist you surrender yourself to the authorities. | I don’t have the time. |
| I lost. Here I lay, at your feet, at your mercy. Just what do you want from me? | Give me something. |
| If so, then won’t you overlook this? Let’s make a deal… | A deal with the enemy? |
| If yer gonna kill me, do me a solid and make it quick. | Aren’t you scared? |
| If you capture me, what you going to do to me? | You’ll be my new stylish coat. |
| I’m a man with a complicated background. The people I know, well… | Complicated…? |
| I’m not going to go easy on you for doing something like this, you know… | Prepare for the worst. |
| In the end, killin’ me’s just a waste of yer time and energy. You get what I’m saying’, right? | It’s not a waste. |
| Maybe I’ll call the police. Maybe I’ll tell ’em that you were worse than you actually were! | Call them. I dare you. |
| Me really want to eat something. | Just endure it. |
| My chest is beating so fast. What is this feeling? | You’re making it up. |
| No matter the crime, humans treat it more lightly if the perpetrator is a minor, do they not? | That’s not true. |
| Seriously, cosplaying in a place like this? Are you just really freakin’ bored? | I’m actually very busy. |
| Somethin’ bad happen in yer life or somethin’, sonny? | You’re getting on my nerves. |
| Tell me, what does “equality” mean to you? | Not talking down to people. |
| That’s how I feel. And is it not pitiable when one denies one’s feelings to oneself? | But the outcome is clear. |
| Um, why’re you going’ for me? Ain’t there worse people out there? What kind of guys piss you off? | Loud talkers… |
| You’ll have a bleak future if you spend too much time running around pretending to be a phantom thief. | Thank you. |
| You carry a gun because you think it’ll make you more popular with the girls? | It won’t? |
| You do know that just pointing that at someone doesn’t actually do anything, right? Buffoon. | Don’t act so tough. |
2.2.3 Timid Shadows
| Question | Best Response(s) |
|---|---|
| A bad rep spreads like wildfire. If I were you, I’d quit all this nonsense. What’s the point? | Good |
| Ah, it’s a shame. If I’d taken this seriously from the start, I wouldn’t be in this sorry state. | Good |
| Ah, so I suppose you commit such extreme acts because you know you won’t be punished harshly… | Good |
| Are all the kids these days doin’ stuff like this? | Good |
| Are there only men’s versions? Where did you get it? | Good |
| As far as you’re concerned, what kind of person was I to you? | Good |
| But I’ve been around the block, so I know–there’s something else you want from me, isn’t there? | Good |
| But what if I ripped your body apart? …What color blood would come pouring out? | Good |
| Care to explain yourself? I certainly hope you have a good reason for this boorish treatment. | Good |
| Couldn’t you at least make me a cup of tea or somethin’? Hell, that’d be real polite. | Good |
| Didn’t you feel like that when you were a kid, too? | Good |
| Do you have a lot of friends? Ever feel like the things they do are annoying? | Good |
| Don’t you think expecting your would-be victim to be receptive to your words is unreasonable? | Good |
| Hell, I got all sorta girls lined up if you’re into that. | Good |
| Hey, if you got any medicine, lend me some. They’re supposed ta work miracles, right…? | Good |
| Hey, let’s play a game! Guess what I wanna eat! | Good |
| Hey mister, if I grew up, what do you think the future me would’ve been like? | Good |
| Hey, mister, will you give me a yummy snack to eat? | Good |
| Hey, sonny if somethin’s been botherin’ you. I’m willing to give you a listen. | Good |
| How did I lose to you? I mean… I win when it comes to looks, ho. | Good |
| How did you find out about me, ho? | Good |
| I insist you surrender yourself to the authorities. | Good |
| I know when I’m gettin’ all sweaty. I’m glistenin’, ain’t I? | Good |
| I lost. Here I lay, at your feet, at your mercy. Just what do you want from me? | Good |
| I suppose that’s why I feel so confused, child. After all, why am I being treated like this? | Good |
| I think the way you’re treating me is “overfamiliar.” I think… | Good |
| I wanted to go on vacation, too, before all this happened… | Good |
| I wish I could see what kind of parents raised you to run loose and wreak havoc like this. | Good |
| I wonder if us speaking together like this now means that we are somehow connected… | Good |
| I would never have accepted this task if I knew it would involve this sort of suffering. | Good |
| If I’d known things would end like this, I wish I had found the courage to ask that girl out… | Good |
| If that’s the plan, well, you better make sure I’m satisfied. | Good |
| Is it not possible for this series of events involving you and me to be attributed to that? | Good |
| Is it scary to get a shot? Does it make you cry, mister? | Good |
| Isn’t that just like when a human woman gets married and moves in with her husband? | Good |
| It is to become aware of the gaze of our Father who watches over you with loving grace. | Good |
| It’d prolly be a big downer if the birthday boy didn’t show to his party, sooo… | Good |
| It’s fine. Do as you please. | Good |
| It’s no fun going home when only my annoying mom and dad are there. | Good |
| Just thinkin’ about hierarchy, you should be showin’ me a little more respect, shouldn’t you? | Good |
| Life’s nothing but pain anyways. Just do whatever you want. | Good |
| Maybe I should try something new! I don’t want to fall into mediocrity, ho… | Good |
| Maybe I’ll call the police. Maybe I’ll tell ’em that you were worse than you actually were! | Good |
| Maybe kids got spanked a long time ago, but people don’t do that anymore, right? | Good |
| Me really want to eat something. | Good |
| Me want to ask some recommendations, so me can at least imagine. | Good |
| Me want you to give me some nice “words of compassion”-as my rival-as me pass away…! | Good |
| Now, people don’t even know who lives next door to them. Shouldn’t we know our neighbors better? | Good |
| Ooh, what if this leaves a scar and it’s permanent? | Good |
| Out of respect for our Father, let us take a moment’s respite… | Good |
| So uh, instead of killin’ me, you started chattin’ with me… You tryin’ to get somethin’ from me? | Good |
| Some old people refuse to make use of special seats reserved for the elderly. What do you think of that? | Good |
| Something about people putting honey on cucumbers to feel like they’re eating fancy cantaloupe…? | Good |
| Sorry, but I want you to go hee-home now. I’m already feeling so tired and weary, ho… | Good |
| The truth is… You’re a good person, aren’t you? | Good |
| This is that “domestic violins” thing, right? | Good |
| To tell you the hee-truth, this is all an act, ho. What do you think I’m really like, ho? | Good |
| To view me as an enemy is to incur our Father’s wrath. Man’s future rests in your hands. | Good |
| Um, why’re you going’ for me? Ain’t there worse people out there? What kind of guys piss you off? | Good |
| Very well. In the place of our Father, I shall listen to your complaints. | Good |
| Well, I need to see myself home soon… | Good |
| You’ll have a bleak future if you spend too much time running around pretending to be a phantom thief. | Good |
2.2.4 Upbeat Shadows
| Question | Best Response(s) |
|---|---|
| Ah, it’s a shame. If I’d taken this seriously from the start, I wouldn’t be in this sorry state. | Bad |
| Are all the kids these days doin’ stuff like this? | No, I thought this up myself. |
| Are there only men’s versions? Where did you get it? | A thrift shop. |
| Aren’t people as old as you s’posed to go “dating,” all the time? Can’t you get some dates? | Right after this, kid. |
| As far as you’re concerned, what kind of person was I to you? | My rival. |
| But I’ve been around the block, so I know–there’s something else you want from me, isn’t there? | I love the elderly. |
| But I’ve got a catch phrase that I’m famous for. | Hee-haw! |
| But what if I ripped your body apart? …What color blood would come pouring out? | Green. |
| Couldn’t you at least make me a cup of tea or somethin’? Hell, that’d be real polite. | I don’t have any. |
| Didn’t you feel like that when you were a kid, too? | Being a kid is tough. |
| Do you have a dish you’re good at? | Fried rice. |
| Don’t take this the wrong way, but man… Bein’ a carefree kid sure must be nice. | I want to be a kid forever. |
| Don’t you think expecting your would-be victim to be receptive to your words is unreasonable? | Don’t fret about it. |
| Guess what I want you to read to me before you tuck me into bed! | I’ll make your sleep eternal. |
| Hell, I got all sorta girls lined up if you’re into that. | You’re trying way too hard. |
| Hey. Aren’t you hungry? Can we take a break and go eat somewhere? | What do you want to eat? |
| Hey, how about this? If you don’t shoot me, then I’ll kiss you. Not a bad deal, right? | Have some self-respect. |
| Hey, if you got any medicine, lend me some. They’re supposed ta work miracles, right…? | Are you OK? |
| Hey, is my hair flat? Does it look weird? | It’s weird looking. |
| Hey, let’s play a game! Guess what I wanna eat! | Hamburgers. |
| Hey mister, if I grew up, what do you think the future me would’ve been like? | A fashionable older woman. |
| Hey, mister, will you give me a yummy snack to eat? | Don’t eat between meals. |
| Hey. So whaddya think when you think about the future? | I just want to enjoy the now. |
| Hey, there’s no need for all this, right? Let’s drop the drama and just go get something to eat. | A famous pancake place. |
| Hey. Why aren’t you at school? | It’s a school holiday. |
| How ’bout you? You wanna get married someday? | That’s impossible. |
| How did I lose to you? I mean… I win when it comes to looks, ho. | It’s all about heart. |
| Humans always want either an autograph or a self-hee, ho. Which is it, ho? | Give me your credit card. |
| I gotta ask. How do you train? | Luck’s usually on my side. |
| I insist you surrender yourself to the authorities. | You’ve got the wrong idea. |
| If your girlfriend asked if you were free to have dinner with her “friends”, what would you say? | Sure. |
| If you capture me, what you going to do to me? | Take you to a taxidermist. |
| I’m a super popular Shadow, you know. My fans won’t just sit around and take this, ho. | Please forgive me. |
| I’m busy, ho. It’s tough being so popular. | You do sound busy. |
| In the very end, what the hell are you tryin’ ta tell me? | Why do we fight? |
| Is it ’cause I wasn’t a “good boy”? | No. |
| Is it scary to get a shot? Does it make |
